Skip to main content

Reply to this post | See parent post | Go Back
View Post [edit]

Poster: grendelschoice Date: Jun 23, 2009 3:10am
Forum: GratefulDead Subject: Re: Rhino/GDP Suck!

Actually, WT, that's kind of my point. I realize I didn;t express it quite as I should have.

What i'd prefer to see, rather than another essay from David Lemieux on the size and cost of the WallofSound--something every Deadhead knows like the alphabet song--is to have them go the extra mile and bring in a rock critic who knows how to write (Blair Jackson is OK but ubiquitous), or even a guest musician (ever read what Elvis Costello has to say about the Dead? It's fantastic), OR--and here's a radical idea...lobby real Deadheads themselves, perhaps folks who actually went to these shows way back when, to offer their own thoughts, just as we do here on the archive.

My point is, I come here primarily to talk about the music...and every time I think I've heard it all, someone usually (not always) steps up and adds a great point about some show or song version that gets me interested all over again.

I noticed that the early Dicks Picks shows had some commentary on the show you just shelled out $20 for, then..they stopped. Just pics and info on length of song, etc. That's to me, just lazy, and if they want folks to keep ponying up, for these RoadTrips, they need to do more. And getting beyond tired old stories about the WOS would be a good start.

Reply to this post
Reply [edit]

Poster: William Tell Date: Jun 23, 2009 7:36am
Forum: GratefulDead Subject: Re: Rhino/GDP Suck!

Wheww...glad my over the top response wasn't offensive. I now realize what you meant but initially wasn't sure.

Funny, I always look for the text in these things, and sometimes am really happy (like Bear's thing on the techno stuff they had to do with TFTV was really interesting...hmmm, that was Bear, right? Anyhow...).

But, many times it really isn't anything new, as we note, and you read it once and are done.

As we note a great packaging job, however, is forever.

I just don't get the cardboard scratchiness thing and they plan for them to go bad after taking them in and out ten times or some such? Would they really do that to us?

Reply to this post
Reply [edit]

Poster: grendelschoice Date: Jun 23, 2009 7:52am
Forum: GratefulDead Subject: Re: Rhino/GDP Suck!

my guess is the cardboard is their "friendly to the earth" less plastics response...but as noted by many makes for a self-defeating scratch problem that makes you have to throw the discs into a landfill where they sit forever anyway.

There's plenty to complain about with these releases, don't get me wrong. I just happen to be a sucker for liner notes in general, and with a little effort they could make these special. There are actually plenty of voices HERE that I would love to hear pontificate in an official release on WHY this or that show deserves its own special spotlight. (Wouldn't you, the esteemed Mr. Tell, welcome the chance to essay on the value of your favorite '68 show? Or hear SDH discuss a stellar '81 release--where are THOSE, btw?)

I'm also just not a "all or nothing" show guy. I rarely listen to an entire show all the way thru (especially the marathon '73 - '74 behemoths with their 45-minute Darkstars) so I don't really get bothered by the chopping up of shows as long as they include the best stuff and the sound is impeccable.

I was listening to the WRS>Jam>OtherOne>It'sASin>StellaBlue from this RT release and damn if I can find a single thing to bitch about there. It's about as good as it gets for '74.

Reply to this post
Reply [edit]

Poster: William Tell Date: Jun 23, 2009 8:22am
Forum: GratefulDead Subject: Re: Rhino/GDP Suck!

Ha--funny, and you're right: the green approach, which I laud, could backfire in this case!

And yeah, I am a sucker too, though I over-stated it above cause I am really pissed about the packaging...can't we have both good packing and notes? C'mon!

Likewise, I really don't care about the whole complete show biz, though I see the point at some level.

Until SCB told me about them, I didn't even realize that two of my fav shows, 4-5-69 and 6-7-70 have a couple of the worst songs on them, ever! I just never listen to the entire thing...